Comments11

From InterSciWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Marcus Nordlund

Thanks for following up on this. If you can get the materials I'll see if a model can be worked up for it. Its an important topic. the Wiley Companion is not the only place to publish, and there is no deadline for an eventual publication. I could see what I can do and take third authorship. In the meantime I wont list you as a potential Wiley authorship but you can always change your mind. I understand the difficulty of being swamped.

-- Best regards, Douglas R. White http://intersci.ss.uci.edu/wiki/index.php/DW_home ________________________________________________________________________ Structure and Dynamics: eJournal of Anthropological and Related Sciences https://submit.escholarship.org/ojs/index.php/imbs_socdyn_sdeas


On 1/8/14, 2:37 AM, Marcus Nordlund wrote: > Hi again, > > here's just a brief note to say that I'm waiting for my colleague to confirm that the list of hits (which, I'm sorry to say, only includes the number of hits and not their location) is indeed accurate and to see if he can dig up the coded data. > > But before we go any further I should perhaps also mention that Jon and I are both swamped with other engagements and would probably find it very difficult to find the time to write a chapter of this kind, even if it does sound like a very interesting challenge. I loathe writing cheques that I'm not sure I can cash, and early-stage realism usually makes everyone's lives a little easier in the long run... > > So--let me know if you're still interested, in which case I'll send you what we have. > > Best regards, > Marcus > Från: Douglas White [douglas.white@uci.edu] > Skickat: den 7 januari 2014 17:01 > Till: Marcus Nordlund; drwhite > Ämne: Re: SV: Nordlund romantic love article > > Good to hear from you and would be happy to have the list of hits... : does it tell which cases are Romantic love? If not is it possible he would have that information? > Whatever he might have as raw coding data would be extremely valuable for putting this data into the SCCS database. > Best, and wishing you a happy new year! > > On 1/7/14, 1:20 AM, Marcus Nordlund wrote: >> Dear Doug, >> >> let me begin by apologising for the tardiness of this reply and by thanking you for your interest in our research. I have now rummaged through my files from 2005, and the only documentation I can offer is a list of "hits" per collection (i.e. the information we offered in the article in question, not the raw coding data). I suspect that this is not what you're after but would be happy to send it to you after checking with my colleague (who was responsible for data collection) that the version I have is indeed the accurate, final version. >> >> Best regards, >> Marcus >> >> Från: Douglas White [douglas.white@uci.edu] >> Skickat: den 18 december 2013 19:23 >> Till: Marcus Nordlund >> Ämne: Nordlund romantic love article >> >>> >> Best Holiday Wishes, Marcus! >> >> As editor-in-chief of the Wiley Companion to Cross-Cultural Research –, book outline attached, with Chapter deadlines Jan 15 2015 - I'd like to explore the possibility that your case-by-case & variable-by-variable database might have enough overlap with regions in the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample (Murdock and White 1969) to form part of our global database (SCCS, EthnoAtlas, Foragers, etc.). If so this would enable you to write a chapter in the book that uses the methodology outlined in the early chapters and exemplified with new modeling in later chapters. I cannot locate the co-author of your Gottschall and Nordlund (2006) so am contacting you. >> >> The start of this experiment would be to send me your data to let me judge whether the overlap is sufficient with the SCCS sample, considered regionally. If so I would include a "regional" version of your data and SCCS regions or representatives of societies or regions, prepare the overlapping datasets for the form of modeling that includes control for Galton's problem (autocorrelation that disturbs valid inference). You have plenty of cases as listed in regional totals, so this may well be possible, especially since the basis of your codes are folktales. This would allow a significant literary-sample scientific contribution to the Companion to Cross-Cultural Research. >> >> I'm aware of course, with the Rosenblatt and Jankoviak and Fischer studies although for the latter data there are only book or article citations with page numbers but after consulting Jankoviak there is no longer any record of the actual codings for the data; the coders who did the work did not retain their documentation. I am hoping you might have for your study the actual codes for each corpus of text. >> -- Thanks for our quik reply today and hopefully in response. >> Am happy to answer any questions you might have. >> Douglas R. White >> http://intersci.ss.uci.edu/wiki/index.php/DW_home >> ________________________________________________________________________ >> Structure and Dynamics: eJournal of Anthropological and Related Sciences >> https://submit.escholarship.org/ojs/index.php/imbs_socdyn_sdeas >


Victor de Munck

Romantic Love and Sexual Behavior: Comparison of Studies (Victor C. de Munck and Janina de Munck] State University of New York at New Paltz, New Paltz, NY, demunckv@gmail.com

  • Invited: to try out the software on the topic with codes for Romantic Love: Victor C. de Munck Comments8 and/or Janina de Munck / Andrey Korotayev
  1. Romantic Love works as a topic because the following no do exist
  2. Rosenblatt's own codes were not published but deMunck and Korotayev DID CODE and PUBLISH the codes for THE FULL 75 societies
  3. Of the 75 deMunck and Korotayev CODED 48 were SCCS societies and these (plus their premarital and extramarital codes) can be added to SCCS
  4. William Jankowiak codes were from other studies, only a few new codes from various ethographers, for cases other than SCCS
  5. thus we can resolve the disagreement between Rosenblatt and Jankowiak with an adequate sample

Doug

On Thu, Nov 29, 2012 at 3:16 PM, Doug White <douglas.white@uci.edu> wrote:

   I have these 5 pubs of yours, Bill:
   William Jankowiak, Monika Sudakov and Benjamin C. Wilreker. 2005. Co-Wife Conflict and Co-operation. Ethnology. Vol. 44, No. 1 (Winter, 2005), pp. 81-98 Published by: University of Pittsburgh.
   William R. Jankowiak and Edward F. Fischer. 1992. A Cross-Cultural Perspective on Romantic Love. Ethnology. Vol. 31, No. 2 (Apr., 1992), pp. 149-155 Published by: University of Pittsburgh.
   William R. Jankowiak, Elizabeth M. Hill, James M. Donovan. 1992. The effects of sex and sexual orientation on attractiveness judgments: An evolutionary interpretation. Ethology and Sociobiology. Volume 13, Issue 2, March 1992, Pages 73–85. 1,3 Department of Anthropology, University of Nevada-Las Vegas, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA, 2 Department of Anthropology, Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA
   'Romantic Passion' by William R. Jankowiak
   'Intimacies: Love and Sex Across Cultures' By William R. Jankowiak
   But nowhere do I find a tabulation (e.g., in table or excel-type format, rows=societies cols=variable names entries=coding categories). Could you make my life simpler and send me the table for your SCCS data on Love, etc.? We can publish it in the SCCS site or in World Cultures, it could be the basis for a chapter in the Wiley Companion we are editing.
   -- thanks and best wishes (you might have page ##s in one or more of these that I have not found!) -- Doug White

Bill:

I am not sure I can find this - for the love study most of the simple math was done on sheets of paper as there were no statistical runs. Worst they were done in word perfect 5.1 and then wp 10 and when everything was transfer to a new computer the word perfect was deleted. I di ot think we did statistical run on the other papers either. But let me take a look at hard copies I might have kept.

I also have the cross-cultural study with ethnology on extramarital affairs and women's reaction. I think that was a 2002 article. I can send that to you if you need it. I also have a wonderful (my opinion) paper on femme fatale - status fatale in Cross- cultural research. I can send that to you too.

The love paper was just present or absence coding. I will email Monika and Will on data they may still have a copy of our coding. Eliz Hill was the number expert for the perception of attraction paper. She may still have the data set - she is very good at this. I am not good with statistics and thus have recruited talented graduate students to assist me - Hill was a young post doc in psych at tulane when we did the study. Bill


Pubs

Jankowiak, William; Nell, M. Diane; Buckmaster, Anne 2002. Extra-Marital Affairs: A Reconsideration of the Meaning and Universality of the 'Double Standard.'. World Cultures 13(1):7:21. Jankowiak, William; Nell, M. Diane; Buckmaster, Anne 2002. Managing Infidelity: A Cross-Cultural Perspective. Ethnology, Vol. 41, No. 1: 85-101. Abstract: Anthropologists have not systematically examined extramarital affairs. Our cross-cultural study found that within every culture men and women actively resort to mate-guarding tactics to control their mate's extramarital behavior. A person's level of interest and involvement does not change with a culture's notion of descent, level of social complexity, or the degree to which a culture is normatively permissive or restrictive in sexual matters. In effect, sexual propriety is the presumed right of both sexes. Our findings are consistent with both the sexual jealousy and the pair-bond hypotheses, which hold that every marriage or love relationship is organized around a presumption of sexual propriety. (Extramarital affair, pair bond, sexual jealousy, human universal).

Jankowiak, William. femme fatale - status fatale in Cross- cultural research.